A jury of five hundred Athenians sentenced an old man to death — just for asking questions.
The Old Philosopher
Socrates was a retired stonecutter. As a young man, he fought in the Peloponnesian War and served in the boule, but he devoted the final years of his life to philosophy. He walked the streets of Athens in worn clothes, attracting a crowd of young men drawn to his relentless questioning.
Yet Socrates often said that he knew how little he knew. The old philosopher engaged his followers in discussions about justice, bravery, and ethics. His questions required students to use logic and examine their own biases and inconsistencies. He believed that we could all find truth by thinking logically and trusting our inner voices. “The unexamined life,” Socrates told the jury at his trial, “is not worth living.”
The Socratic Method
When teachers ask questions that encourage students to draw conclusions, they are using the “Socratic method” of teaching. This approach helps students learn by thinking through problems themselves rather than merely accepting a teacher’s words.
Writing and Debate
Socrates never wrote a book. He argued that a written text gives the same fixed answer to everyone and cannot explain itself or defend an idea when challenged. Without debate, readers might mistake memorizing words for true understanding. Socrates believed truth was best tested through real-time conversation.
What we know about Socrates comes mostly from his student, Plato. Plato recorded his teacher’s ideas in dialogues — written conversations where thinkers test ideas through questioning.
The Gadfly
Socrates called himself a “gadfly” — a biting pest trying to “sting” a sluggish city into action. He hoped his criticism would push Athens to recover the greatness it lost in the Peloponnesian War. Today, persistent critics are still called gadflies.
Socrates opposed democracy, arguing that governing required wisdom, not merely citizenship. Athens selected many officials by lottery, which Socrates considered reckless. No one chose a ship’s captain or a doctor by lottery; why select leaders that way? He believed crowds were easily swayed by confident speakers, especially Sophists who could make a weak argument sound strong.
The Trial of Socrates
To anxious Athenians, Socrates was not a harmless eccentric — he was teaching youth to disrespect the city. In 399 BCE, accusers brought him to trial. Because he spoke of a private, divine inner voice, accusers charged him with refusing to honor Athens’ gods, introducing fake deities, and corrupting the youth.
A jury of 501 Athenian men listened as Socrates defended himself. Instead of begging for mercy, the old philosopher questioned his accusers and vowed to keep examining Athenian lives. In a narrow vote, the jurors convicted him.
When required to propose his own penalty, the old philosopher audaciously suggested free meals for life — an honor reserved for Olympic heroes. He later offered to pay a fine backed by his friends, but the outraged jury sentenced him to die by drinking poisonous hemlock.
The Death of Socrates
Socrates’s friends offered to bribe the guards and help him escape from prison, but the philosopher refused. Though treated unjustly, he insisted that returning a wrong for a wrong was never justified. To break the law now would mean he was a fraud. A good life, he argued, mattered more than a long one. Socrates calmly drank the poison, dying for the principles he spent a lifetime testing.
Resources
Download this lesson as a worksheet with activities
Editable File (Microsoft Word)
Printable PDF (Adobe Acrobat)
Mr. Donn has an excellent website that includes a section on Ancient Greece.